Middle-Earth Quest / Similar games

18 games like Middle-Earth Quest

The best games like Middle-Earth Quest are War of the Ring Second Edition, Arkham Horror and Descent Journeys in the Dark — the closest of 18 ranked alternatives, scored by shared mechanics and category. War of the Ring Second Edition shares adventure, fantasy, novel-based with Middle-Earth Quest.

Every alternative below links to its own Middle-Earth Quest-style fact page, drawn from MeeplePick’s adventure / exploration shelf.

Ranked by shared category (3 pts) and mechanics (2 pts), bonus within 0.7 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 3.5 weight, then BoardGameGeek’s Bayesian rating — one entry per series, 18 shown.

As an Amazon Associate, MeeplePick earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

1. 

   1. War of the Ring Second Edition (2012)

   2–4 players · 150–180 min · ★ 8.5 · Medium-heavy · See War of the Ring Second Edition alternatives →

   Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Fantasy, Novel-based, Hand Management · 4 shared tags · 1 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (25%)

   vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · ~15 min shorter · +0.6 heavier

   Check price for War of the Ring Second Edition →
2. 

   2. Arkham Horror (2005)

   1–8 players · 120–240 min · ★ 7.3 · Medium-heavy · See Arkham Horror alternatives →

   Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Fantasy, Novel-based, Hand Management, Point to Point Movement · 5 shared tags · 2 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (50%)

   vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · plays solo · scales to 8 · about the same length · same complexity

   Check price for Arkham Horror →
3. 

   3. Descent Journeys in the Dark (2005)

   2–5 players · 120–240 min · ★ 7.3 · Medium · See Descent Journeys in the Dark alternatives →

   Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Exploration, Fantasy, Team-Based Game, Variable Player Powers · 5 shared tags · 2 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (50%)

   vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · scales to 5 · about the same length · 0.2 lighter

   Check price for Descent Journeys in the Dark →
4. 

   4. Tainted Grail The Fall of Avalon (2019)

   1–4 players · 60–120 min · ★ 8.3 · Medium · See Tainted Grail The Fall of Avalon alternatives →

   Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Exploration, Fantasy, Hand Management · 4 shared tags · 1 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (25%)

   vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · plays solo · ~90 min shorter · 0.3 lighter
5. 

   5. Fury of Dracula (Third/Fourth Edition) (2015)

   2–5 players · 120–180 min · ★ 7.5 · Medium · See Fury of Dracula (Third/Fourth Edition) alternatives →

   Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Novel-based, Point to Point Movement, Team-Based Game, Variable Player Powers · 5 shared tags · 3 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (75%)

   vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · scales to 5 · ~30 min shorter · 0.3 lighter
6. 

   6. Eldritch Horror (2013)

   1–8 players · 120–240 min · ★ 7.8 · Medium · See Eldritch Horror alternatives →

   Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Fantasy, Novel-based, Point to Point Movement · 4 shared tags · 1 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (25%)

   vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · plays solo · scales to 8 · about the same length · 0.2 lighter
7. 

   7. Fury of Dracula (Second Edition) (2005)

   2–5 players · 180 min · ★ 7.1 · Medium · See Fury of Dracula (Second Edition) alternatives →

   Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Novel-based, Point to Point Movement, Team-Based Game, Variable Player Powers · 5 shared tags · 3 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (75%)

   vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · scales to 5 · about the same length · 0.6 lighter
8. 

   8. The Lord of the Rings The Card Game (2011)

   1–2 players · 30–60 min · ★ 7.7 · Medium · See The Lord of the Rings The Card Game alternatives →

   Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Fantasy, Novel-based, Hand Management · 4 shared tags · 1 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (25%)

   vs Middle-Earth Quest: both play at 2 · plays solo · ~135 min shorter · 0.4 lighter
9. 

   9. Mysthea Essential Edition (2019)

   2–5 players · 90 min · ★ 7.8 · Medium-heavy

   Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Exploration, Fantasy, Hand Management, Variable Player Powers · 5 shared tags · 2 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (50%)

   vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · scales to 5 · ~90 min shorter · +0.2 heavier
10. 

    10. Shadows of Brimstone City of the Ancients (2014)

    1–4 players · 120 min · ★ 8.0 · Medium · See Shadows of Brimstone City of the Ancients alternatives →

    Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Exploration, Fantasy, Variable Player Powers · 4 shared tags · 1 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (25%)

    vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · plays solo · ~60 min shorter · 0.2 lighter
11. 

    11. Arkham Horror (Third Edition) (2018)

    1–6 players · 120–180 min · ★ 7.8 · Medium · See Arkham Horror (Third Edition) alternatives →

    Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Novel-based, Point to Point Movement, Variable Player Powers · 4 shared tags · 2 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (50%)

    vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · plays solo · scales to 6 · ~30 min shorter · 0.3 lighter
12. 

    12. Vast The Mysterious Manor (2019)

    1–5 players · 60–120 min · ★ 7.6 · Medium-heavy

    Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Exploration, Fantasy, Hand Management, Variable Player Powers · 5 shared tags · 2 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (50%)

    vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · plays solo · scales to 5 · ~90 min shorter · +0.2 heavier
13. 

    13. Dungeon Twister Paladins & Dragons (2004)

    2 players · 60 min · ★ 7.5 · Medium

    Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Exploration, Fantasy, Hand Management, Variable Player Powers · 5 shared tags · 2 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (50%)

    vs Middle-Earth Quest: both play at 2 · ~120 min shorter · 0.4 lighter
14. 

    14. Mansions of Madness (2011)

    2–5 players · 120–180 min · ★ 7.3 · Medium · See Mansions of Madness alternatives →

    Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Exploration, Fantasy, Hand Management · 4 shared tags · 1 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (25%)

    vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · scales to 5 · ~30 min shorter · 0.3 lighter
15. 

    15. The Battle of Five Armies (2014)

    2 players · 90–240 min · ★ 7.9 · Medium-heavy

    Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Fantasy, Novel-based, Hand Management · 4 shared tags · 1 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (25%)

    vs Middle-Earth Quest: both play at 2 · ~15 min shorter · same complexity
16. 

    16. Too Many Bones (2017)

    1–4 players · 60–120 min · ★ 8.4 · Medium-heavy · See Too Many Bones alternatives →

    Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Fantasy, Hand Management · 3 shared tags · 1 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (25%)

    vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · plays solo · ~90 min shorter · +0.3 heavier
17. 

    17. World of Warcraft The Boardgame (2005)

    2–6 players · 180 min · ★ 6.7 · Medium-heavy · See World of Warcraft The Boardgame alternatives →

    Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Fantasy, Hand Management, Team-Based Game, Variable Player Powers · 5 shared tags · 3 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (75%)

    vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · scales to 6 · about the same length · same complexity
18. 

    18. Solomon Kane (2021)

    1–5 players · 60–120 min · ★ 8.3 · Medium

    Shares with Middle-Earth Quest: Adventure, Exploration, Fantasy, Novel-based, Variable Player Powers · 5 shared tags · 1 of Middle-Earth Quest’s 4 mechanics (25%)

    vs Middle-Earth Quest: overlaps at 2–4 players · plays solo · scales to 5 · ~90 min shorter · 0.5 lighter

Looking for the original? See the full Middle-Earth Quest fact page — players, play time, age and complexity.